Posts

Showing posts with the label All Quiet on the Western Front

A century on, two films answer the current moment

Image
The past couple of days have been filled with dread. The President of the United States has upped the ante for his claim to dictator. If he does, in fact, destroy Iran - the country, its culture, its people - he will have consigned the U.S. to the blackest pit of history. If he executes this diabolical plan, he will find himself at the head of the list of despots and geoncidists. Yes, I believe ahead of Hitler, Mao, and Stalin. Why? Because by now, we should have learned from history. But “should have” does a lot of lifting here. After all, I am referring to a man who knows nothing of history, who cares nothing for others - either as individuals or simply as humanity. I cannot recall anyone in my lifetime who appears to embody ignorance and hatred so completely.  Of course, he doesn’t act alone. He has begun an unconstitutional and illegal war. He was able to do so because, so far, Congress has abdicated its role as the arbiter for declaring war. Indeed, Congress has abdicated its ...

“All Quiet on the Western Front”; a handsome, if remote endeavor

Image
It’s not the film’s fault that “All Quiet on the Western Front” left me strangely unmoved. That might sound odd, but I hope what I follow that with makes a modicum of sense.   If I hadn’t seen the first film adaptation from 1930, if I hadn’t seen other, equally and perhaps more so, visceral re-enactments of life and death on the battlefield, I might have been more drawn in. However, I have, and I wasn’t. Germany’s entry for - among other categories - Best International Film and Best Motion Picture is most assuredly A Prestige Picture. At the same time, it has too much else going for it to be merely Oscar bait TM . For one thing, it does present in unflinching detail that kids are cannon fodder and the great lie of any country that resorts to mass murder to settle accounts or for that matter, attempt to force the rest of the world to bend a knee is that it is a civilized polity. At one point, a battle weary Kat tells our main character Paul that men are beasts. This is borne out ...