Posts

Showing posts with the label Bebe Daniels

Comparisons are Odious: the earlier adaptations of Hammett’s “The Maltese Falcon”

Image
For decades, I put off seeing either Roy del Ruth’s 1931 version of Dashiell Hammett’s novel, much less 1936’s “Satan Met a Lady.” I am glad I got around to them for several reasons, but before we get to those in order to treat them more on their own grounds, most people would probably want to know how they measure up to the John Huston classic.  They don’t.  There. That should do it, except that I know it doesn’t. Actually, let’s just get into them and as I go along, I’ll make some notes about what Huston and his cast and crew did that made 1941’s “The Maltese Falcon” the masterwork it is. For starters, both of the earlier films treat the story as a lightweight comedy to varying degrees. The earlier version is more faithful to the book and while Ricardo Cortez is immensely charming and naturalistic in his performance, he plays Sam Spade as more of a devilish cad than a world-weary private eye. William Warren’s iteration as “Ted Shane” (all the characters’ names were cha...