The Coen Canon - “Burn After Reading” (Who are you?! Who do you work for?!)
The first time I saw “Burn After Reading”, I was genuinely confused, by Carter Burwell’s score as much as, if not more than, anything unfolding plot wise. Why did they go with such intrusive and portentous music? How are these characters so fucking stupid? (There’s no other adjective I can use that would do justice to these dopes.) Why am I watching this? And then, somewhere, it clicked. Somewhere, Brad Pitt’s Benicio Del Toro without a brain expression won me over, Clooney’s mugging and ludicrous pillow talk with uber ice queen Tilla Swinton did the trick, Malkovich unhinged, and McDormand’s utterly, undeservedly optimistic health club administrator, conquered my resistance. And all of them dumber than a box of hammers. Essentially, what I found was a script so smart that it overcame my resistance. In one sense, this is the Coens’ corollary to expertly told horror movies; you buy into the stupid choices the characters make because the script is tight enough to make it work a...