Posts

Showing posts with the label farce

The Problem with Adaptations and Changed Times - The Roses (2025)

Image
Right off the bat, I really liked The Roses . A lot. It’s not as dark a comedy as one might be led to believe, but it is farce. This sets it apart from satire by default, and the choices made by Tony McNamara’s script reflect a considerable difference in emphasis from the source material or Danny DeVito’s classic The War of the Roses . I mention this because The Roses is a solid piece of entertainment that works on its own, but seems to suffer in comparison with the earlier works. This points up a problem with adaptations in general. It is often the case that “the book is better than the movie”. There are exceptions, the notable ones that come to my mind are King’s The Shining and Kubrick’s adaptation; both are fine - and one is a genuinely great work of cinema - as they are; American Psycho ; where the film was much livelier, coherent and funny than the novel. Barry Giffords’ Wild at Heart and Lynch’s adaptation are both on equal tier to me. You get the idea. But what happens when ...

Like Whodunnits? Go see “See How They Run”

Image
I don’t know that I want to say “Knives Out” spurred a renewed interest in the “whodunnit” genre, but I’m tempted to say that “See How They Run” is the first since then that does justice to the genre. “Knives Out” is a more grounded, generally more fully realized and original work; but “See How They Run”’s script by Mark Chappell does a fine job of taking a screwball approach to it. I won’t go into a lot of detail about the plot because I could well give away who done it. That said, just quickly; the movies opens on a voiceover by Hollywood director Leo Kopernick, played to perfection by Adrien Brody and recounts how hacky and predictable drawing room murder mysteries and how he is at a party with the cast and crew of Agatha Christie’s “The Mousetrap” since he wants to be in line to direct the movie adaptation. Oh, and he is speaking from the afterlife, having been murdered in the theater during a performance.  The case is assigned to Inspector Stoppard (Sam Rockwell) and Const...